My 4 Sons BBQ Opens Second Location in Gig Harbor

BY AVERY GOODSTINE for WEEKLY VOLCANO | 11/20/26

My 4 Sons BBQ recently found a second home in Gig Harbor and it’s a step up from the original Tacoma location, coming in at 1,700-square-feet larger and equipped with a full bar.

Located at 7704 Pioneer Way, the Gig Harbor location has been operating regularly for about a month. There are plans for a grand opening during the first or second week of December.

Matt Henning, owner of the BBQ joint, said he hopes to transition the hours to 11:30 a.m. to 8 p.m. or 9 p.m. Wednesdays through Sundays. The goal is to capitalize on the lunch rush crowd he’s expecting at this location, which is something the Tacoma location doesn’t have.

Henning opened the first location at 9823 Portland Ave. E in Tacoma in March 2018. Luckily for them, when the world shut down during COVID, Henning said they were able to pivot their business and really thrive off of takeout orders.

With the growth of the Tacoma location, Henning said the next step was to open a second location in Wisconsin, where his wife and parents are from and where a few of his sons live now.

However, when the Gig Harbor location became available, Henning seized the opportunity to take over the former Brimstone PNW Smokehouse location.

“I didn’t know anything about it, just saw the listing. It popped up in my email, so I sent the broker a message,” Henning said. “Came out here and looked at it. Said, ‘Oh wow, didn’t realize that this was out here,’ and I thought it’s kind of cool. The building was cool. Everything, I mean, the bones were great. The structure was good. A lot of stuff we liked. Then tried Brimstone’s food, and it was good barbecue. But we thought we can really do something out here.”

My 4 Sons BBQ is named after, you guessed it, Henning’s four sons.

Before opening up the shop, Henning would travel around the country for work and try out the barbecue wherever he landed. Then he would come home, try and recreate what he had eaten, and his sons would be the taste testers.

“That’s where we came up with My 4 Sons BBQ, because all the recipes, all the menu items are all approved by the four sons,” he said. “They ate them, they tried them, they tweaked them, and so that’s how we came up with it.”

Henning said they had always been a barbecue family. He enjoyed smoking large quantities of meat, and when there are five boys in the house, barbecue is an easy way to feed all those hungry mouths.

While all four sons worked for the joint at some point, none of them stuck around Washington.

The oldest (30) is an elementary school principal in Portland, the next oldest (28) is in Wisconsin with plans to open a third location there, the third oldest (21) is a college senior in Wisconsin, and the youngest (18) is a college freshman in Wisconsin.
With the oldest being around 22 when Henning opened the first location, he said they all saw how much work it takes to open a business. But, they were able to offer their insight as well.

“The older two had worked at other restaurants before we opened, and then they came to work for us, and they were able to do stuff, improve on stuff that they saw,” he said. “And so they brought their expertise in and said, ‘By the way, this isn’t the good way to do it. Here’s a better way to do it.’ So it was helpful to start off with that.”

Having been to many states and eaten loads of barbecue, Henning confidently named his favorite spots for different kinds of meat.
Lexington Barbecue in North Carolina has his favorite pork, and he prefers the vinegar and ketchup-based sauce North Carolina barbecue is known for, as opposed to the mustard-based (aka Carolina Gold) sauce in South Carolina.

His favorite brisket is from Texas, and Kansas City takes the crown for burnt ends.

When it comes to ribs, Henning said it’s a tie between Memphis and Kansas City.

When pulling inspiration from his favorite places for his own menu, Henning said it was less about the cooking technique and more about the flavor profiles, which all comes down to the dry rub and the kind of wood you use when cooking.

“We really built everything off of our rub, and that rub took a while to put together,” he said, noting the importance in the type of wood used to influence the flavor profiles. “You got your post oak down South, and then you’ve got different pecans on the West Coast. You’ve got different woods on the East Coast, and we like hickory. It just gives a nice robust flavor, and it spreads well across all our meats, so that’s something we picked up.”

The dry rub took some time to finalize, and Henning said he still has the 20-something different variations they tried before landing on the final recipe.

He described it as having a “tinge of sweet” without using any sugar, and it has a little bit of heat that is easy to build on.
Everything at My 4 Sons is made in-house and fresh for the day. That means when they run out, they are out for the rest of the day.

They serve brisket, ribs, pulled pork, pulled chicken, smoke-fried wings, and a BBQ sundae, which is mac and cheese, BBQ beans, your choice of meat, coleslaw, and pickles served in a cup.

Side dishes include mac and cheese, smoked BBQ beans, coleslaw, potato salad, broccoli salad, mini cornbread muffins, and brownies.

Smoked turkey is available on Thursdays, rib tips on Fridays, and burnt ends on Saturdays.